ANOTHER REASON TO ABOLISH THE INCOME TAX--PRIVACY
Many Americans see the demand by Richard Neal, the Chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee, for President Trump’s income tax returns as a sideshow that has little effect on them. They know that Mr. Neal and the President will employ legions of lawyers and probably nothing will happen for years. They also recognize that political pundits will talk about this situation endlessly.
CONFIDENTIALITY OF INCOME TAX RETURNS
Defenders of the income tax often have asserted that even though all of us are required, under penalty of perjury—if we lie we have committed a criminal offense--that the returns are confidential. Most people think that their personal information on their federal tax returns is confidential. This is true—to a point.
The law relating to the confidentiality of income tax returns is stated in 26 U.S. Code § 6103 Confidentiality and disclosure of returns and return information.
The section that applies to this request is:
6103(f) Disclosure to Committees of Congress
(1)Committee on Ways and Means, Committee on Finance, and Joint Committee on Taxation
Upon written request from the chairman of the Committee on Ways and Means of the House of Representatives, the chairman of the Committee on Finance of the Senate, or the chairman of the Joint Committee on Taxation, the Secretary shall furnish such committee with any return or return information specified in such request, except that any return or return information which can be associated with, or otherwise identify, directly or indirectly, a particular taxpayer shall be furnished to such committee only when sitting in closed executive session unless such taxpayer otherwise consents in writing to such disclosure.
In an article written for Politico entitled Why Congress Might Not Get Trump's Tax Returns, Ross Garber, an attorney specializing in political investigations, gave an analysis of the current law. Mr. Garber pointed out that while IRS Code 6103(f) appears to give the committee the power to get the tax returns, the Supreme Court has held that Congress can’t use its powers to delve into someone’s private financial matters unless there is a proper legislative purpose and that Congress is not a “law enforcement agency” that can seek information to uncover or expose crimes.
As the title of his article states, unless the House moves to impeach the President, they will have some serious problems obtaining the tax returns.
IF PRESIDENT TRUMP PROVIDES THE TAX RETURNS WILL THEY BE KEPT SECRET?
Although there is no law requiring a President or candidate for President to release their federal income tax returns, it has been a standard practice since 1973.
Few of us are naïve enough to believe that if the Ways And Means Committee obtained the President’s income tax returns, that they would not be leaked to the press. Doing this would be a federal crime, but there is a much easier way for a Member to make the returns public that is immune from prosecution.
Article 1, Section 6 of the U.S. Constitution states:
The Senators and Representatives shall receive a Compensation for their Services, to be ascertained by Law, and paid out of the Treasury of the United States. They shall in all Cases, except Treason, Felony and Breach of the Peace, be privileged from Arrest during their Attendance at the Session of their respective Houses, and in going to and returning from the same; and for any Speech or Debate in either House, they shall not be questioned in any other Place.
Because of this provision in the Constitution, if a Member of the Ways And Means Committee went on the floor of the House and discussed the President’s income tax returns and even placed them in the public record, there is almost no chance of prosecution—assuming that they “appeared” to be conducting legislative business.
Even if a court ruled that the releasing of the income tax returns was improper, it would be too late. Providing his income tax returns to the Ways And Means Committee is almost certainly the same as the President making them public.
THE QUESTION THAT SHOULD BE ASKED BUT ISN’T
Americans instinctively know that if a government can abuse the rights of one citizen, they can abuse the rights of other citizens. The question for Congress and the President is why should Americans be forced to submit income tax returns at all when there is a more efficient way to fund the government—the FAIRtax.
Many “income tax protestors” have argued that making you complete a federal income tax return and sign it under penalty of perjury is actually a violation of both the Fourth and Fifth Amendments to the Constitution.
The Fourth Amendment states:
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.
The Fifth Amendment states:
No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the Militia, when in actual service in time of War or public danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offence to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.
While the right to privacy is not explicitly guaranteed by the Fourth Amendment, many court decisions have relied on the Fourth Amendment to justify determining that there was a right to privacy for one group or another.
The Fifth Amendment protects a person from being “compelled to be a witness against himself.” Strictly speaking, filing an income tax return and saying that it is true is being a “witness against yourself.”
Of course, the courts have held that these arguments are invalid when made by income tax protestors. Many in Congress correctly point out that when you fill out a loan form, a driver’s license form or a myriad of other forms that you are giving up privacy and are being a witness against yourself in that it could be a criminal offense if the information is incorrect.
There is a difference—filing an income tax form is mandatory and if you don’t, it can subject you to civil and even criminal penalties. Doing the other filings is your choice and if you don’t drive there is no need to apply for a driver’s license—for example.
The Swamp and many Members of Congress delight in any events that will draw our attention away from the truth—this entire income tax disclosure drama is unnecessary. If we had a sane tax system like the FAIRtax, there would be no need for any of us to expose our private information about our income and spending to anyone—unless we chose to do so.
Sometimes we forget that opposition to the present income/payroll tax system is not just opposition to a system that:
- Economically is far worse than the FAIRtax.
- Imposes a huge record-keeping and reporting burden on Americans that would not be needed under the FAIRtax.
- Continues to reduce job creation the U.S.
- Continues to be almost impossible to understand.
- Continues to be widely evaded—a projected $9 trillion in the next decade.
If they can obtain the President’s federal income tax returns and, with no civil or criminal liability, reveal them to the world, they can do it to anyone else they believe is a threat. Even if we are not concerned about anything being revealed, we still are not eager to have our data widely available to all when it was supposed to be confidential.
Freedom from this type of government control over our lives is what for many years made the U.S. so different from the rest of the world. The Swamp and their Member allies agree with Adolf Hitler’s statement, How fortunate for governments that the people they administer don't think.
The Swamp and their Member allies are eroding our freedoms every day and, make no mistake, they are doing this for the purposes of controlling us so that they can make enormous profits at our expense.
Martin Niemoller, the Lutheran pastor who was sent to a concentration camp by the Nazis and died there, said,
First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a socialist.
Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out— because I was not a trade unionist.
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.
Some say that the way to speak out is with violence or civil unrest. However, we can strike a mighty blow for freedom by working together to rid the Swamp and their Members of Congress of a tool that enriches them and provides them control over us—the income/payroll tax system.
Isn’t it time to take back control from D.C.?
President Trump, “Embrace the FAIRtax and real tax reform! What have you got to lose?”
It is time to PASS THE FAIRTAX!
The truth is the truth. Remember, if we don't continue to tell the truth and demand a change, then this quote from George Orwell's 1984 may foretell our children's future:
“If you want a picture of the future, imagine a boot stamping on a human face—forever.”
Call up the local or D.C. offices of your House Member and two Senators and you can use the following script:
WHAT CAN EACH OF US DO
- I am sure that Representative ____ or Senator ____ is in favor of everyone obeying the income tax laws.
- After they assure you that their boss is not in favor of anyone breaking the law, ask if they are aware of the Cebula study showing $9 trillion of evaded income/payroll taxes over the next ten years.
- Since most will say they don’t believe their boss has seen the study, either drop off a copy or get an email address and send a copy to them for their boss.
- Say you are going to call back in a week and ask what the Representative or Senator is going to do to stop this evasion.
- In a week, call back and ask specifically what the Representative or Senator is going to do to enforce the law.
- They probably will say their boss believes that simplifying the income tax will handle the problem.
- Explain that when people evade income taxes, they are also evading the 15.3% payroll/Medicare tax and state income tax. So it is unlikely that they are going to pay 30% or 40% when they were paying 0% because they have already decided it is okay to cheat.
- Say that the only way to reduce evasion is to increase by tens or hundreds of thousands the number of comprehensive IRS audits done each year.
- Point out that Evaders do not self-identify by putting an “E” on their income tax return.
- 80% of the people likely to be audited are trying to comply, but they will be forced to endure these IRS audits as well.
- Ask if the Member is in favor of this?
- If they say no, then ask again how the Member proposes to stop people breaking the income tax laws.
- Then explain that the way to handle evasion without unleashing the IRS audits is the FAIRtax.
If you can see your Member or attend a town hall and ask these questions, you can be even more effective.
FAIRTAX POWER RADIO
#155 Questions, Suggestions, Comments & Tax News?
This episode featured comments and suggestions from our listeners plus news hot off the wire such as:
- ‘Can the FAIRtax be made more Congress Friendly by including a campaign fund?’ (paraphrased).
- FAIRtax Power Radio works! New volunteer and database specialists found for AFFT.
- News report: Minimum wage hikes trigger ‘payroll tsunami’ as Steve Hayes predicted.
- Congress trying to set a record for proposed changes to the tax code.
Another great discussion with comments coming in Live from our Facebook viewers in addition to those emailed prior to the show. This was a truly interactive show for The FAIRtax Guys, AFFT board members, devoted listeners and other FAIRtax supporters around the country.
Share our podcasts and our new website with everyone you know.
Did he say “new website?” Why, yes, he did.
We have yet another way for you to enjoy FAIRtax Power Radio/TV. And you don’t have to “join” anything or “subscribe” to any site. Just go to fairtaxguys.com to see our latest effort in getting the FAIRtax news spread far and wide
If you believe the FAIRtax is good for America, let others know by turning them onto FAIRtax Power Radio - the ONLY weekly FAIRtax digital TV show in the country! Watch every Wednesday at 11:30 AM (ET) on Facebook LIVE (www.facebook.com/fairtax). If you can’t watch live or you don’t use Facebook, go to fairtaxguys.com to watch the show and keep up with the latest events.
FTPR podcasts for each show are posted on Spreaker (http://bit.ly/2oesbk7), iTunes & iHeart Radio every Friday morning. A free FAIRtax Power Radio app is available for iOS and Android. Since it’s a podcast, you can download it and play it whenever it’s convenient for you.
The FTPR weekly episodes are shared to a number of Facebook pages:
- FAIRtax Official (https://www.facebook.com/FairTax/)
- The FAIRtax Guys (https://www.facebook.com/thefairtaxguys/)
- Democrats for FAIRtax (https://www.facebook.com/DemocratsForFairTax/)
- And many others. Don’t forget the new website: fairtaxguys.com
Please help us educate as many Americans about the FAIRtax as possible. Be sure to tell everyone you know about this great new format for FAIRtax Power Radio. Whether you watch the weekly video or listen to the weekly podcast, this is a great way for more Americans to learn about the best tax reform plan in Congress at this time.
Remember, FTPR digital TV every Wednesday at 11:30 AM (ET) followed by the podcast on Friday morning and the new website (fairtaxguys.com) anytime. Please watch, listen, and tell everyone you know about the FAIRtax Power Radio. The FAIRtax: Once You Understand It, You’ll Demand It!
AMERICA’S BIG SOLUTION - THE FAIRTAX PRIMER AMERICA NEEDS
Hard to believe but there still are people who have not heard of the FAIRtax.
For those people, America’s Big Solution provides a starting point in their study of the FAIRtax and is meant for people of any age. And you can download it to your tablet or smartphone right now. It’s also available in print form. See below.
Do you know someone who would like an introduction to the FAIRtax and would prefer to read about it in a booklet rather than search online for Tweets, Posts and Shares? If so, America’s Big Solution is their best choice.
America’s Big Solution is an introduction to the FAIRtax written by Terry Tibbetts, author of A Spartan Game: The Life and Loss of Don Holleder, with help from Ron Maiellaro, President of the Florida FAIRtax Educational Association.
You can buy an electronic version of ABS as follows: AMERICA’S BIG SOLUTION is available for only $2.99 for the Amazon Kindle (http://amzn.to/1WIRHry), the Barnes & Noble Nook (http://bit.ly/1XeG8bH) and Apple iOS (http://apple.co/1tnqK0P).
You can purchase a print copy at the same Amazon link above for $9.25. Regardless of whether you choose the electronic format or the print format, you’ll find AMERICA’S BIG SOLUTION will give someone the boost they need to begin their study of the FAIRtax and the suggested resources to learn more. Buy AMERICA’S BIG SOLUTION now!
LINKS TO MORE INFORMATION
These links will help you promote and support the FAIRtax, make yourself familiar with the links below. We always do our best to keep our AFFT community up to date, and you can stay ahead of the curve using these convenient sites.
- The website of Americans for Fair Taxation (www.fairtax.org)
- Read the Summary of the Evasion Study
- Welcome to the Online FAIRtax Community (member.fairtax.org)
- The free website of The FAIRtax Guys (fairtaxguys.com)
- The website at which you can help make it happen (bigsolution.org)
- The Facebook page for Americans for Fair Taxation
- The Facebook page for The FAIRtax Guys
- The Twitter page for Americans for Fair Taxation
- YouTube channel for AFFT
- YouTube channel for The FAIRtax Guys
- The Official FAIRtax Logo Store (www.fairtaxlogostore.org)
- POPVOX - Make your FAIRtax voice heard on this national self-survey platform
Thank You for Opening The FAIRtax Chronicles, Our Sponsored Mailings
We plan to do several of these mailings each month. If you take a minute to open the sponsored emails and click through to the website, you are making an in kind contribution to AFFT. It is not required to actually make a purchase, but your minute of time will ensure that AFFT is paid ever larger amounts from people paying for us to send their offers to our supporters.
Again, we are making every effort to ensure that we work with only reputable companies. If you feel that any FAIRtax-sponsored email is objectionable, please email us at firstname.lastname@example.org and tell us why. You can also opt to not receive these sponsored email messages but still receive FAIRtax emails.
Thank you for staying FAIRtax strong!